ヤマタニ/IWESEP2014
をテンプレートにして作成
[
トップ
] [
新規
|
一覧
|
検索
|
最終更新
|
ヘルプ
]
開始行:
[[ヤマタニ]]
*IWESEP2014＠中之島 [#oe44080c]
&attachref(IWESEP2014 参加報告.pptx);
**title [#n1f1fc94]
An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evolution: ...
**abstruct [#he514af2]
We propose an exploratory analysis method for software re...
**review [#z4f9a824]
----------------------- REVIEW 1 ---------------------
PAPER: 11
TITLE: An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evol...
AUTHORS: Yosuke Yamatani and Masao Ohira
OVERALL EVALUATION: 1 (weak accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 2 (low)
----------- REVIEW -----------
This paper proposes a method for an exploratory analysis ...
Pros:
- The problem of the correlation analysis of two time ser...
http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/7727/how-to-co...
http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/23993/how-to-c...
http://www.eecs.qmul.ac.uk/~ccloy/project_time_delayed/...
http://maxi.riken.jp/FirstYear/proceedings/pdf/Scargle_...
http://maxi.riken.jp/FirstYear/ppt/O26SCARGLE.pdf
http://www.itc.nl/~rossiter/teach/R/R_ts.pdf
- The paper studied various metrics from three OSS projec...
Cons:
- The result section is not easy to understand. For examp...
- The proposed method tends to show illusory correlation ...
Minor comments:
- Section I, 3rd paragraph: in step after the delay from ...
- Section III-B, 3rd paragraph: into a single data point....
- Section IV-A, last line: grayed part in Figure 2 <- the...
----------------------- REVIEW 2 ---------------------
PAPER: 11
TITLE: An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evol...
AUTHORS: Yosuke Yamatani and Masao Ohira
OVERALL EVALUATION: 1 (weak accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 3 (medium)
----------- REVIEW -----------
Summary:
This paper proposes a technique to take into account the ...
The authors conducted an empirical study with three OSS p...
The authors checked all the possible combinations of the ...
Pros:
+ The considered problem is important.
+ The approach proposed in this paper makes sense to cope...
+ The empirical study found some hidden correlations, whi...
Comments:
- The authors said "we propose an exploratory analysis me...
- How should practitioners use the proposed technique? In...
Minor Comments:
- p.1 left column; duplicate statement "in step after the...
- p.2 right column; wrong citation "[Isida2008]"
- p.2 right column; I'm wondering that "N(N-1)/2 * 12^3" ...
- p.3 left column; Why do data points for the explanatory...
- p.3 left column; "put together into a single data point...
- p.3 right column; "Note that regular correlation analys...
- p.3 right column; "# of committed changes" is redundant.
- p.4 right column and p.5 left column; there exist some ...
- p.5 left column; "it can be seen that DCA *extracts* th...
- p.5 left column; "In this paper, we implement *a* case ...
- p.5 right column; "it is revealed unexpected *events*"
- p.5 right column; "A proposal method can assist for *re...
- p.5 the section of DISCUSSION; the section seems to lac...
----------------------- REVIEW 3 ---------------------
PAPER: 11
TITLE: An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evol...
AUTHORS: Yosuke Yamatani and Masao Ohira
OVERALL EVALUATION: 0 (borderline paper)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 4 (high)
----------- REVIEW -----------
I fundamentally disagree with the idea of randomly lookin...
At first, I didn’t understand how your delayed correlatio...
I don’t understand the results that you have. How can you...
終了行:
[[ヤマタニ]]
*IWESEP2014＠中之島 [#oe44080c]
&attachref(IWESEP2014 参加報告.pptx);
**title [#n1f1fc94]
An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evolution: ...
**abstruct [#he514af2]
We propose an exploratory analysis method for software re...
**review [#z4f9a824]
----------------------- REVIEW 1 ---------------------
PAPER: 11
TITLE: An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evol...
AUTHORS: Yosuke Yamatani and Masao Ohira
OVERALL EVALUATION: 1 (weak accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 2 (low)
----------- REVIEW -----------
This paper proposes a method for an exploratory analysis ...
Pros:
- The problem of the correlation analysis of two time ser...
http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/7727/how-to-co...
http://stats.stackexchange.com/questions/23993/how-to-c...
http://www.eecs.qmul.ac.uk/~ccloy/project_time_delayed/...
http://maxi.riken.jp/FirstYear/proceedings/pdf/Scargle_...
http://maxi.riken.jp/FirstYear/ppt/O26SCARGLE.pdf
http://www.itc.nl/~rossiter/teach/R/R_ts.pdf
- The paper studied various metrics from three OSS projec...
Cons:
- The result section is not easy to understand. For examp...
- The proposed method tends to show illusory correlation ...
Minor comments:
- Section I, 3rd paragraph: in step after the delay from ...
- Section III-B, 3rd paragraph: into a single data point....
- Section IV-A, last line: grayed part in Figure 2 <- the...
----------------------- REVIEW 2 ---------------------
PAPER: 11
TITLE: An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evol...
AUTHORS: Yosuke Yamatani and Masao Ohira
OVERALL EVALUATION: 1 (weak accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 3 (medium)
----------- REVIEW -----------
Summary:
This paper proposes a technique to take into account the ...
The authors conducted an empirical study with three OSS p...
The authors checked all the possible combinations of the ...
Pros:
+ The considered problem is important.
+ The approach proposed in this paper makes sense to cope...
+ The empirical study found some hidden correlations, whi...
Comments:
- The authors said "we propose an exploratory analysis me...
- How should practitioners use the proposed technique? In...
Minor Comments:
- p.1 left column; duplicate statement "in step after the...
- p.2 right column; wrong citation "[Isida2008]"
- p.2 right column; I'm wondering that "N(N-1)/2 * 12^3" ...
- p.3 left column; Why do data points for the explanatory...
- p.3 left column; "put together into a single data point...
- p.3 right column; "Note that regular correlation analys...
- p.3 right column; "# of committed changes" is redundant.
- p.4 right column and p.5 left column; there exist some ...
- p.5 left column; "it can be seen that DCA *extracts* th...
- p.5 left column; "In this paper, we implement *a* case ...
- p.5 right column; "it is revealed unexpected *events*"
- p.5 right column; "A proposal method can assist for *re...
- p.5 the section of DISCUSSION; the section seems to lac...
----------------------- REVIEW 3 ---------------------
PAPER: 11
TITLE: An Exploratory Analysis for Studying Software Evol...
AUTHORS: Yosuke Yamatani and Masao Ohira
OVERALL EVALUATION: 0 (borderline paper)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 4 (high)
----------- REVIEW -----------
I fundamentally disagree with the idea of randomly lookin...
At first, I didn’t understand how your delayed correlatio...
I don’t understand the results that you have. How can you...
ページ名:
![[PukiWiki]](image/wadanyan.png "[PukiWiki]")
