higashi/IWESEP2016_reviews
をテンプレートにして作成
[
トップ
] [
新規
|
一覧
|
検索
|
最終更新
|
ヘルプ
]
開始行:
[[higashi]]
*TITLE: Clustering OSS License Statements Toward Automati...
*AUTHORS: Yunosuke Higashi, Yuki Manabe and Masao Ohira [...
**IWESEP2016 REVIEWS PAPER 19[#wba44397]
***----------- REVIEW1 ----------- [#db2be394]
This paper presented an approach to automatically cluster...
Points in favour
This paper tackles an interesting problem which is both r...
Points against
In the grep step, to identify the BSD licenses, the autho...
-BSD3の条件"neither the name"と"all advertising materials...
In the discussion, the authors explained the rationale be...
-RECALLの言及がない
The authors calculated the precision/recall/F-value for t...
-SLCやSFのメトリクスはスタンダードじゃない．grepステップ...
***----------- REVIEW2 ----------- [#sf8e4d16]
This paper proposes a method to more efficiently check th...
One major issue with the paper, however, is the clarity o...
For condition alpha it is easy enough to understand by lo...
The beta condition was quite difficult to understand even...
Algorithms for bigram and trigram word clustering
Sven Martin, Joerg Liermann, Hermann Ney
Speech communication
-条件αとbetaの説明がわかりにくい．条件betaは，以下の論文...
There were quite a few typos (e.g. "sometimes sometimes",...
-タイポグラフィー
It would also be interesting to use a more supervised app...
-教師あり学習アプローチを使ってみれば，より面白いものにな...
***----------- REVIEW3(dmg?) ----------- [#i099f376]
The paper describes an approach to automatically infer li...
Overall, the paper addresses an interesting problem. The ...
This statement is not entirely true since a licensor coul...
-Ninka，Fossologyのどの部分をサポートするのかを明確にする...
-"GPL/BSDは，正規表現を使うことで，バージョンと，オプショ...
-開発者が追加した条項や，リンク例外，Apache v1.1などを分...
The use of clustering to infer license rules is interesti...
Contrary to what is claimed in the paper, Ninka performs ...
-論文に描かれていることに反して，Ninkaは，スペルミスや，...
The paper should be proof-read to correct the multiple ty...
Some Typos:
clusters which are are suitable -> clusters which are sui...
to be reused -> a large number of licenses sometimes must...
For the GLP license family -> For the GPL license family
Pourpose-> Purpose
終了行:
[[higashi]]
*TITLE: Clustering OSS License Statements Toward Automati...
*AUTHORS: Yunosuke Higashi, Yuki Manabe and Masao Ohira [...
**IWESEP2016 REVIEWS PAPER 19[#wba44397]
***----------- REVIEW1 ----------- [#db2be394]
This paper presented an approach to automatically cluster...
Points in favour
This paper tackles an interesting problem which is both r...
Points against
In the grep step, to identify the BSD licenses, the autho...
-BSD3の条件"neither the name"と"all advertising materials...
In the discussion, the authors explained the rationale be...
-RECALLの言及がない
The authors calculated the precision/recall/F-value for t...
-SLCやSFのメトリクスはスタンダードじゃない．grepステップ...
***----------- REVIEW2 ----------- [#sf8e4d16]
This paper proposes a method to more efficiently check th...
One major issue with the paper, however, is the clarity o...
For condition alpha it is easy enough to understand by lo...
The beta condition was quite difficult to understand even...
Algorithms for bigram and trigram word clustering
Sven Martin, Joerg Liermann, Hermann Ney
Speech communication
-条件αとbetaの説明がわかりにくい．条件betaは，以下の論文...
There were quite a few typos (e.g. "sometimes sometimes",...
-タイポグラフィー
It would also be interesting to use a more supervised app...
-教師あり学習アプローチを使ってみれば，より面白いものにな...
***----------- REVIEW3(dmg?) ----------- [#i099f376]
The paper describes an approach to automatically infer li...
Overall, the paper addresses an interesting problem. The ...
This statement is not entirely true since a licensor coul...
-Ninka，Fossologyのどの部分をサポートするのかを明確にする...
-"GPL/BSDは，正規表現を使うことで，バージョンと，オプショ...
-開発者が追加した条項や，リンク例外，Apache v1.1などを分...
The use of clustering to infer license rules is interesti...
Contrary to what is claimed in the paper, Ninka performs ...
-論文に描かれていることに反して，Ninkaは，スペルミスや，...
The paper should be proof-read to correct the multiple ty...
Some Typos:
clusters which are are suitable -> clusters which are sui...
to be reused -> a large number of licenses sometimes must...
For the GLP license family -> For the GPL license family
Pourpose-> Purpose
ページ名:
![[PukiWiki]](image/wadanyan.png "[PukiWiki]")
