山崎/buggy review
をテンプレートにして作成
[
トップ
] [
新規
|
一覧
|
検索
|
最終更新
|
ヘルプ
]
開始行:
[[山崎]]
-[[議事録>buggy review/議事録]]
**ポスター発表での指摘点 [#mce0015b]
-クリティカル？
--"コードレビュー内の単語数"と相関がないか確認する必要が...
--（ざっくり言うと）単語からバギーになるか予測しているが...
--バギーとクリーンで実際に議論内容が違うことの根拠は？そ...
--ナイーブベイズのP(c)をちゃんと調整している？
-直せる
--"コードレビューの議論内容"が何を指しているか伝わりづらい
--訓練/テストデータを9:1にしたほうがいいのでは
--プロジェクト足し合わせてデータ数増やしたほうがいいのでは
--既存研究+αの予測モデルだと過学習を起こすのでは
--cinderプロジェクトは半数がバギーレビューだけどそもそも...
--文章を特徴量にするくだりの説明が足りていない
**既存研究のメトリクス一覧 [#ica31c25]
-C. Tantithamthavorn, S. McIntosh, A. E. Hassan, and K. M...
--Recent works [74, 90, 91, 99, 144] explore the relation...
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|[74]O. Kononenko, O. Baysal, L. Guerrouj, Y. Cao, ...
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Technical|Size (LOC)|||
|~|Chunks|||
|~|Number of files|||
|~|Module|||
|~|&color(red){Priority};|||
|~|Severity|||
|~|Super review|||
|~|Number of previous patches|||
|~|Number of writer’s previous patches|||
|Personal|Review queue|||
|~|Reviewer experience|||
|~|Reviewer experience for module|||
|~|Writer experience|||
|~|Writer experience for module|||
|Participation|Number of developers on CC|||
|~|Number of comments|||
|~|Number of commenting developers|||
|~|Average number of comments per developer|||
|~|&color(blue){Number of reviewer comments};|||
|~|Number of writer comments|||
~
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|[90]S. McIntosh, Y. Kamei, B. Adams, and A. E. Has...
|>|>|>|[91]S. McIntosh, Y. Kamei, B. Adams, and A. E. Has...
|>|>|>|[99]R. Morales, S. McIntosh, and F. Khomh, “Do cod...
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Product|Size|||
|~|Complexity|||
|Process|&color(red){Prior defects};|||
|~|Churn|||
|~|Change entropy|||
|Human Factors|&color(green){Total authors};|||
|~|Minor authors|||
|~|Major authors|||
|~|Author ownership|||
|Coverage|Proportion of reviewed changes|||
|~|Proportion of reviewed churn|||
|~|Reviewer experience for module|||
|Participation|Proportion of self-approved changes|||
|~|Proportion of hastily reviewed changes|||
|~|Proportion of changes without discussion|||
|~|[91]Typical review window|||
|~|[99]Typical discussion length|||
~
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|[144]P. Thongtanunam, S. McIntosh, A. E. Hassan, a...
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Control|Size|||
|~|Churn|||
|~|Entropy|||
|~|#Contributor|||
|~|#Author|||
|~|#Reviewer|||
|Code Authorship|Top TCO|||
|~|Top RSO|||
|Review-Aware Ownership||||
|~|Proportion of minor author & major reviewer|||
|~|Proportion of major author & major reviewer|||
|~|Proportion of minor author & minor reviewer|||
|~|Proportion of major author & minor reviewer|||
~
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|P. Thongtanunam, S. McIntosh, A. E. Hassan, and H....
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Review Intensity|Number of Iterations|||
|~|&color(blue){Discussion Length};|||
|~|Proportion of Revisions without Feedback|||
|~|Churn during Code Review|||
|Review Participation|Number of Reviewers|||
|~|&color(green){Number of Authors};|||
|~|Number of Non-Author Voters|||
|~|Proportion of Review Disagreement|||
|Reviewing Time|Review Length|||
|~|Number of Authors|||
|~|Response Delay|||
|~|Average Review Rate|||
終了行:
[[山崎]]
-[[議事録>buggy review/議事録]]
**ポスター発表での指摘点 [#mce0015b]
-クリティカル？
--"コードレビュー内の単語数"と相関がないか確認する必要が...
--（ざっくり言うと）単語からバギーになるか予測しているが...
--バギーとクリーンで実際に議論内容が違うことの根拠は？そ...
--ナイーブベイズのP(c)をちゃんと調整している？
-直せる
--"コードレビューの議論内容"が何を指しているか伝わりづらい
--訓練/テストデータを9:1にしたほうがいいのでは
--プロジェクト足し合わせてデータ数増やしたほうがいいのでは
--既存研究+αの予測モデルだと過学習を起こすのでは
--cinderプロジェクトは半数がバギーレビューだけどそもそも...
--文章を特徴量にするくだりの説明が足りていない
**既存研究のメトリクス一覧 [#ica31c25]
-C. Tantithamthavorn, S. McIntosh, A. E. Hassan, and K. M...
--Recent works [74, 90, 91, 99, 144] explore the relation...
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|[74]O. Kononenko, O. Baysal, L. Guerrouj, Y. Cao, ...
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Technical|Size (LOC)|||
|~|Chunks|||
|~|Number of files|||
|~|Module|||
|~|&color(red){Priority};|||
|~|Severity|||
|~|Super review|||
|~|Number of previous patches|||
|~|Number of writer’s previous patches|||
|Personal|Review queue|||
|~|Reviewer experience|||
|~|Reviewer experience for module|||
|~|Writer experience|||
|~|Writer experience for module|||
|Participation|Number of developers on CC|||
|~|Number of comments|||
|~|Number of commenting developers|||
|~|Average number of comments per developer|||
|~|&color(blue){Number of reviewer comments};|||
|~|Number of writer comments|||
~
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|[90]S. McIntosh, Y. Kamei, B. Adams, and A. E. Has...
|>|>|>|[91]S. McIntosh, Y. Kamei, B. Adams, and A. E. Has...
|>|>|>|[99]R. Morales, S. McIntosh, and F. Khomh, “Do cod...
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Product|Size|||
|~|Complexity|||
|Process|&color(red){Prior defects};|||
|~|Churn|||
|~|Change entropy|||
|Human Factors|&color(green){Total authors};|||
|~|Minor authors|||
|~|Major authors|||
|~|Author ownership|||
|Coverage|Proportion of reviewed changes|||
|~|Proportion of reviewed churn|||
|~|Reviewer experience for module|||
|Participation|Proportion of self-approved changes|||
|~|Proportion of hastily reviewed changes|||
|~|Proportion of changes without discussion|||
|~|[91]Typical review window|||
|~|[99]Typical discussion length|||
~
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|[144]P. Thongtanunam, S. McIntosh, A. E. Hassan, a...
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Control|Size|||
|~|Churn|||
|~|Entropy|||
|~|#Contributor|||
|~|#Author|||
|~|#Reviewer|||
|Code Authorship|Top TCO|||
|~|Top RSO|||
|Review-Aware Ownership||||
|~|Proportion of minor author & major reviewer|||
|~|Proportion of major author & major reviewer|||
|~|Proportion of minor author & minor reviewer|||
|~|Proportion of major author & minor reviewer|||
~
|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|CENTER:|c
|>|>|>|P. Thongtanunam, S. McIntosh, A. E. Hassan, and H....
|''Type''|''Metric''|''Description''|''Rationale''|h
|Review Intensity|Number of Iterations|||
|~|&color(blue){Discussion Length};|||
|~|Proportion of Revisions without Feedback|||
|~|Churn during Code Review|||
|Review Participation|Number of Reviewers|||
|~|&color(green){Number of Authors};|||
|~|Number of Non-Author Voters|||
|~|Proportion of Review Disagreement|||
|Reviewing Time|Review Length|||
|~|Number of Authors|||
|~|Response Delay|||
|~|Average Review Rate|||
ページ名:
![[PukiWiki]](image/wadanyan.png "[PukiWiki]")
