まつ本/STC2008
をテンプレートにして作成
[
トップ
] [
新規
|
一覧
|
検索
|
最終更新
|
ヘルプ
]
開始行:
[[まつ本]]
#contents
*概要 [#z6a954b5]
**STC 2008 [#x6c02136]
- URL~
-- http://docs.google.com/View?id=dhncd3jd_89fpszqcx&pli=1~
- Important Dates
-- Paper submission deadline: 3 March 2008
-- Notification to authors: 31 March 2008
-- Final papers due: 21 April 2008
- page limit: 10
**title[#uee49c77]
%%A Comparison Study on the coordination patterns in oss ...
A Comparison Study on the Coordination Between Developers...
**authors [#j7a3924e]
Shinsuke Matsumoto, Yasutaka Kamei, Masao Ohira and Ken-i...
*log [#x396e78e]
//-2008// &attachref();~
-2008/05/27 &attachref(stc_2008_cam.ready.pdf); カメラレ...
-2008/03/04 &attachref(stc_2008_final.pdf); 投稿バージョン~
-2008/03/02 &attachref(stc_2008_080302.pdf); 5,6章英語化...
-2008/02/28 &attachref(stc_2008_080228.pdf); 3章英語化+大...
-2008/02/24 &attachref(stc_2008_080224.pdf); 考察，関連研...
-2008/02/23 &attachref(stc_2008_080223.pdf); 結果~
-2008/02/18 &attachref(stc_2008_080218.pdf); まだ適当~
-2008/02/15 &attachref(stc_2008_080215.pdf); 適当~
*todo [#ib5d9159]
*review results [#ded38e8f]
**reviewer 1 [#v7109148]
-メール使い分けている人をどうするのか？
-定義がいろんな場所に書いてあって読みにくい
-captionを詳しく書いたほうが良い
-------------------- review 1 --------------------
OVERALL RATING: 2 (accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 4 (expert)
Is this paper a good candidate for a major presentation...
----------------------- REVIEW --------------------
Brief summary:
The authors argue, based a case study of Apache & Netsc...
who bridge user and developer communities are the most ...
success of open source projects. The study considered b...
of open source projects, and the dynamic change in the ...
While it is well known that highly motivated developers...
of the community, the "bridging behaviour" of key peopl...
and users, is an interesting phenomenon.
Evaluation:
THe paper offers an interesting case study. The results...
but they are potentially interesting and relevant, and ...
for study and discussion.
There are some problems with the work.
THe authors don't seem to have done any aliasing resolu...
multiple email aliases; without resolving these, the da...
networks are suspect.
Definitions are scattered too much in the paper. There ...
section that defines all the metrics. IN fact, I could ...
anywhere. i assumed this was degree?
I suggest using detailed captions. Figures, tables etc ...
to follow if they are fully self-describing.
Some other comments:
Figure 7 is very hard to read. Please add a detailed ca...
Page 1, right column, end of second para, last sentence:
"developers who communicated with more developers contr...
section 6.1, para 2 "Highly motivated developers are in...
**reviewer 2 [#l09b7fc1]
-MLとnewsgroupの差異があやしい
-Pd-uが本当にコーディネータやってるのか？
-送受信関係のネットワークそのものについて
-もっといいメトリクスないのか
-
-dynamic analysisに対するノイズとかの説明は
-文章，特に4.2.2
-------------------- review 2 --------------------
OVERALL RATING: 2 (accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 4 (expert)
Is this paper a good candidate for a major presentation...
----------------------- REVIEW --------------------
Brief summary:
The manuscript presents a study of Apache and Netscape ...
mail-group and newsgroup communication networks. Email ...
contribute to both user and developer groups were a par...
target. The links between email addresses are defined a...
immediate post-response relationship in the discussion
threads. Average path length and clustering coefficient...
presented for entire user/developer network, for the us...
and for the developer network. Only developer networks ...
substantially different (presumably at least partially ...
Netscape developers are collocated and have alternative...
newsgroup communication).
The top five emails for Apache and Netscape that partic...
developer and user lists are tracked over time finding ...
Netscape email addresses had uneven participation over ...
presumably reflecting down-sizing, churn, and eventual ...
project.
Evaluation:
Clearly, understanding communication networks in genera...
roles of developer/user-group-spanning individuals is o...
Furthermore, work demonstrates that some of the dramati...
between the two projects are also somewhat reflected in...
network measures.
There are, however, a number of questions about what ex...
findings may mean.
First question that jumps out is the differences betwee...
(where each message is mailed to each subscriber) and n...
(where anyone interested can read some of the messages ...
in time). This push versus pull is likely to affect the
reader/poster behavior and may explain at least some of...
differences. The presented explanation that it is irre...
believable.
The second big question relates to the definition of th...
group (posters to user and developer lists). Are they i...
moderating feature request transition from users to dev...
hypothesized in the paper or are they serving some othe...
There appears to be no attempt to validate that assumpt...
minimal requirements (say number of posts or responses ...
both lists) to qualify them as moderators of user requi...
The third big issue relates to exact meaning of the pre...
post-response pair in the newsgroups and in mailing lis...
really establish a social connection (can the prolific ...
recall even a tenth of the email addresses they have he...
it reflecting something else, and if so what?
Without answers to these questions it is hard to judge ...
measures and charts mean, so the remaining comments are...
The absence of clear differences in the summary measure...
the entire and user groups is quite disconcerting. The ...
after all, drastically different and it is surprising t...
network measures have quite similar values. Could it be...
measures would capture the difference, or was it an unl...
that the particular aspects that these measures capture...
similar? If so why?
The difference in the graph layout charts, while pronou...
not likely to be reproducible (both in terms of layout ...
most importantly, in terms of interpretation).
It is not clear if the results of the dynamic analysis ...
or signal. In any case it is not clear what the finding...
even less clear what they may mean.
Text, especially sect. 4.2.2 needs numerous corrections
and clarifications.
*memo [#je7dc789]
リポジトリ: http://tun.naist.jp/svn/Empirical/shinsuke-m/...
*ストレスの掃き溜め場 [#ha39f93a]
- 宇和あああああああああああああああああああああああああ...
- in this study wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww we wwwwewewwwe うぃ...
- ALCが逝ってしまわれた嗚呼嗚呼あああああああざおらるざお...
- 「流氷と共にやってきたアザラシをカレーにしてみました」...
- 「NASAが公開した新型オフロード月面車」ｗｗｗｗｗｗｗお...
- 盛ｗｗｗｗｗｗりｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗ上ｗｗｗｗｗがっ...
- ｳﾋｮｰーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーー...
- ｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗ...
- あｗｗｗげｗｗｗるｗｗｗなｗｗｗ -- &new{2009-07-30 (...
- ごｗｗｗめｗｗｗんｗｗｗなｗｗｗさｗｗｗいｗｗｗｗｗｗ...
#comment
終了行:
[[まつ本]]
#contents
*概要 [#z6a954b5]
**STC 2008 [#x6c02136]
- URL~
-- http://docs.google.com/View?id=dhncd3jd_89fpszqcx&pli=1~
- Important Dates
-- Paper submission deadline: 3 March 2008
-- Notification to authors: 31 March 2008
-- Final papers due: 21 April 2008
- page limit: 10
**title[#uee49c77]
%%A Comparison Study on the coordination patterns in oss ...
A Comparison Study on the Coordination Between Developers...
**authors [#j7a3924e]
Shinsuke Matsumoto, Yasutaka Kamei, Masao Ohira and Ken-i...
*log [#x396e78e]
//-2008// &attachref();~
-2008/05/27 &attachref(stc_2008_cam.ready.pdf); カメラレ...
-2008/03/04 &attachref(stc_2008_final.pdf); 投稿バージョン~
-2008/03/02 &attachref(stc_2008_080302.pdf); 5,6章英語化...
-2008/02/28 &attachref(stc_2008_080228.pdf); 3章英語化+大...
-2008/02/24 &attachref(stc_2008_080224.pdf); 考察，関連研...
-2008/02/23 &attachref(stc_2008_080223.pdf); 結果~
-2008/02/18 &attachref(stc_2008_080218.pdf); まだ適当~
-2008/02/15 &attachref(stc_2008_080215.pdf); 適当~
*todo [#ib5d9159]
*review results [#ded38e8f]
**reviewer 1 [#v7109148]
-メール使い分けている人をどうするのか？
-定義がいろんな場所に書いてあって読みにくい
-captionを詳しく書いたほうが良い
-------------------- review 1 --------------------
OVERALL RATING: 2 (accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 4 (expert)
Is this paper a good candidate for a major presentation...
----------------------- REVIEW --------------------
Brief summary:
The authors argue, based a case study of Apache & Netsc...
who bridge user and developer communities are the most ...
success of open source projects. The study considered b...
of open source projects, and the dynamic change in the ...
While it is well known that highly motivated developers...
of the community, the "bridging behaviour" of key peopl...
and users, is an interesting phenomenon.
Evaluation:
THe paper offers an interesting case study. The results...
but they are potentially interesting and relevant, and ...
for study and discussion.
There are some problems with the work.
THe authors don't seem to have done any aliasing resolu...
multiple email aliases; without resolving these, the da...
networks are suspect.
Definitions are scattered too much in the paper. There ...
section that defines all the metrics. IN fact, I could ...
anywhere. i assumed this was degree?
I suggest using detailed captions. Figures, tables etc ...
to follow if they are fully self-describing.
Some other comments:
Figure 7 is very hard to read. Please add a detailed ca...
Page 1, right column, end of second para, last sentence:
"developers who communicated with more developers contr...
section 6.1, para 2 "Highly motivated developers are in...
**reviewer 2 [#l09b7fc1]
-MLとnewsgroupの差異があやしい
-Pd-uが本当にコーディネータやってるのか？
-送受信関係のネットワークそのものについて
-もっといいメトリクスないのか
-
-dynamic analysisに対するノイズとかの説明は
-文章，特に4.2.2
-------------------- review 2 --------------------
OVERALL RATING: 2 (accept)
REVIEWER'S CONFIDENCE: 4 (expert)
Is this paper a good candidate for a major presentation...
----------------------- REVIEW --------------------
Brief summary:
The manuscript presents a study of Apache and Netscape ...
mail-group and newsgroup communication networks. Email ...
contribute to both user and developer groups were a par...
target. The links between email addresses are defined a...
immediate post-response relationship in the discussion
threads. Average path length and clustering coefficient...
presented for entire user/developer network, for the us...
and for the developer network. Only developer networks ...
substantially different (presumably at least partially ...
Netscape developers are collocated and have alternative...
newsgroup communication).
The top five emails for Apache and Netscape that partic...
developer and user lists are tracked over time finding ...
Netscape email addresses had uneven participation over ...
presumably reflecting down-sizing, churn, and eventual ...
project.
Evaluation:
Clearly, understanding communication networks in genera...
roles of developer/user-group-spanning individuals is o...
Furthermore, work demonstrates that some of the dramati...
between the two projects are also somewhat reflected in...
network measures.
There are, however, a number of questions about what ex...
findings may mean.
First question that jumps out is the differences betwee...
(where each message is mailed to each subscriber) and n...
(where anyone interested can read some of the messages ...
in time). This push versus pull is likely to affect the
reader/poster behavior and may explain at least some of...
differences. The presented explanation that it is irre...
believable.
The second big question relates to the definition of th...
group (posters to user and developer lists). Are they i...
moderating feature request transition from users to dev...
hypothesized in the paper or are they serving some othe...
There appears to be no attempt to validate that assumpt...
minimal requirements (say number of posts or responses ...
both lists) to qualify them as moderators of user requi...
The third big issue relates to exact meaning of the pre...
post-response pair in the newsgroups and in mailing lis...
really establish a social connection (can the prolific ...
recall even a tenth of the email addresses they have he...
it reflecting something else, and if so what?
Without answers to these questions it is hard to judge ...
measures and charts mean, so the remaining comments are...
The absence of clear differences in the summary measure...
the entire and user groups is quite disconcerting. The ...
after all, drastically different and it is surprising t...
network measures have quite similar values. Could it be...
measures would capture the difference, or was it an unl...
that the particular aspects that these measures capture...
similar? If so why?
The difference in the graph layout charts, while pronou...
not likely to be reproducible (both in terms of layout ...
most importantly, in terms of interpretation).
It is not clear if the results of the dynamic analysis ...
or signal. In any case it is not clear what the finding...
even less clear what they may mean.
Text, especially sect. 4.2.2 needs numerous corrections
and clarifications.
*memo [#je7dc789]
リポジトリ: http://tun.naist.jp/svn/Empirical/shinsuke-m/...
*ストレスの掃き溜め場 [#ha39f93a]
- 宇和あああああああああああああああああああああああああ...
- in this study wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww we wwwwewewwwe うぃ...
- ALCが逝ってしまわれた嗚呼嗚呼あああああああざおらるざお...
- 「流氷と共にやってきたアザラシをカレーにしてみました」...
- 「NASAが公開した新型オフロード月面車」ｗｗｗｗｗｗｗお...
- 盛ｗｗｗｗｗｗりｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗ上ｗｗｗｗｗがっ...
- ｳﾋｮｰーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーーー...
- ｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗｗ...
- あｗｗｗげｗｗｗるｗｗｗなｗｗｗ -- &new{2009-07-30 (...
- ごｗｗｗめｗｗｗんｗｗｗなｗｗｗさｗｗｗいｗｗｗｗｗｗ...
#comment
ページ名:
![[PukiWiki]](image/wadanyan.png "[PukiWiki]")
